
“It is not worth an intelligent man’s time to be in the majority. By definition, there are already enough people to do that.” – G. H. Hardy
If this is the case. How do you transfer the balance of intelligence to much needed causes than the herd?
“It is impossible to defeat an ignorant man in argument.”
By definition impossible means never being able to defeat said man. Is it possible to educate said man? how do you educate to prevent ignorance?
These two quotes have driven my mind mad all week. That coupled with my curiosity to watch how people react in times of stress. I am not sure if I have written/alluded to this before, but I am always fascinated by how people conform or rebel in groups. People can be like lab rats fight based on their personal assessment and will to live.
Business School
Not that I want to compare lab rats to graduate students but I think I have too. You drop 60 motivated students in a classroom to sink or swim, and they will swim or at least sink trying. In the process to stay alive they will also lean on you to stay above water. They don’t care if that means you have less air or are even submerged under the water. they will do what they need to do to survive and prosper. No other place will you be in a room with 60 very similar people with their initial instinct to be divide and conquer. You know when you walk in that room that admissions has already sorted you as the best and the brightest to attend that program. At least by one standard deviation, everyone in that room had tested and scored very close to the same. Otherwise you wouldn’t of been admitted. I recently heard of a study where they dropped a lab rat into two exactly the same containers in shape, size and, water level. The only different is that one will be placed in a dark room and the other will in a lighted room. The rat in the dark will give up after 30 seconds of swimming, while the one exposed to light in the otherwise same conditions will fight and swim for over 4 hours. An effort equaled to 500 times greater.
What is the fundamental difference? The rat in the dark has no hope, the exposure to light creates an inherent driver of motivation to survive. Similar to graduate students they are all the same, they are all in the same container and they are all in the same amount of water. Unlike the test environment where there is one person controlling the exposure to light, instead all of your peers are the ones with their hands on the switch. Students will shut off their peers light as they compete and dismiss those who they feel don’t their equal. (Which is interesting because an admissions board has declared all of them the same and equal). It is the nature and conditions of their surroundings.
California Sports Fan
This sports fan is always an interesting topic for me. I was serenaded by the California cry daily when I arrived here. “Where else can you surf in the morning and drive to ski in the afternoon.” This mindset is why very few professional sports teams survive let alone thrive. Who have survived regularly LA Lakers because of “SHOWTIME” the flash and glamour drive the market. LA Doyers (Dodgers) because they were pioneers.
Who does not thrive: LA Kings, Anaheim Ducks, San Diego anything. Why? Is it because California produces more flakey people than any where else? Is it because the Northeast is more hard core than any where else? I am sure these stereotypes have a hair of truth, but the reality we are all a product of our environment.
Why is Southern California filled with more transplants (yes transplants, not implants) than any where else? Because it is an active community. The gym after work is a social standard not a new years resolution. Tanning, running, biking, surfing are weekend rituals because they can be. It is november 7th and I am in a robe and not much else and I am fine. If I was still in NYC I would be buried in layers and a neck deep in adult beverages because there is not much to do but watch sports and drink beers. That is the product of that environment, that is why people seem/claim to be harder works in NYC. They have no choice but to stay at work or indoors to support their team instead of attempting to brave the cold. As much as I get frustrated during NY Yankee playoff baseball because I am in the heart of LA Angel red. It isn’t because the Angels are not a well coached team (Except in game 1,2 or 5 in the 2009 ALCS). It is because the Angels fans are short sighted and limited in their exposure because of their balanced social and sporting life.
City Life/Dating
Big city dating is survival of the fittest. I saw a great article in the NY Times on how living in Manhattan limits your ability to date the bridge & tunnel crowd. On a map the distance between parts of Manhattan and sections of queens is about 15 miles or 20 minutes driving in most places. Because of the density of people in a city, it will take over an hour and 3 trains to visit a partner. You could be also exposed to a 100,000 singles in a radius of 15 blocks, so why would you look as far as 15 miles. Clearly it doesn’t make sense.
NYC is not easy or cheap living. It is a frenzy for most and this intoxicating concentration of choice and options can quickly limit or erase your future options. I know people who have submerged in the deep and fruitful garden of eden we call New York City, Chicago and/or San Francisco. Catching fish after fish and living it weekend after weekend. Next thing you know you are 45 years old and HBO has made a movie about you as either Carrie or Big depending on your gender.
New York!!!!
Concrete jungle where dreams are made of,
There’s nothing you can’t do,
Now you’re in New York!!!
These streets will make you feel brand new,
the lights will inspire you,
Let’s hear it for New York, New York, New York – Alicia Keys
My uncle always said that some drugs make you brand new, and a new man always wants more. It hits me like a wave where I envy this lifestyle an then I remember that the city is really just a legal drug that can consume you until it is done with you. It is amazing but extremely addictive and dangerous.
Public vs Private HS
I have had the luxury to experience both sides sort of. I grew up in the inner-boroughs of NYC seeing the diversity and melting pot of the city. There was not happy bubble or fairy tale blanket of naive bliss.
I also was moved to a suburban High School in Connecticut to a some what exclusive neighborhood. All those after school stories or TV sitcoms on how rich children act is very accurate. I like to believe that the more intimate smaller classrooms provided in the nicer some what private schools allow for a lot of exploration. Curiosity and communication can really develop a young child. It sets building blocks that could build a strong foundation. Curiosity has also killed the cat.
In public schools things happen fast and decisions are made. It can happen in both settings, but it seems that there is a greater chance for poor choices in public schools. Again it is the product of their environment. I am bias towards smaller more private schools but I know they are both as equally dangerous. Any extra time on your hands means getting into your parents booze, smokes and dirty magazines. Kids will be kids and I had the benefit or working fast and learning to hustle. Then being conditioned and sculpted in the private setting second. I don’t think a suburban kid could be dropped into a urban HS unless they have watch Michelle Pfeiffer in Dangerous Minds.
Unions
Unions by definition protect the weakest employee. They are a band of brothers that limit each others progress. I speak freely about this knowing that I was raised in a union household. They are the prototype for the herd mentality.
Definition: The term herd mentality is derived from the word “herd,” meaning group of animals, and “mentality,” implying a certain frame of mind. However the most succinct definition would be: how large numbers of people act in the same ways at the same times.
Herd behavior is distinguished from herd mentality because it applies to all animals, whereas the term “mentality” implies a uniquely human phenomenon. Herd mentality implies a fear-based reaction to peer pressure which makes individuals act in order to avoid feeling “left behind” from the group. Herd mentality is also sometimes known as “mob mentality.”
Conclusion
What was my goal with this post? I wanted to identify how herds operate in different settings.
Herd mentality describes how people are influenced by their peers to adopt certain behaviors, follow trends, and/or purchase items. Examples of the herd mentality include the early adopters of high technology products such as cell phones and iPods, as well as stock market trends, fashions in apparel, cars, home décor, etc. Social psychologists study the related topics of group intelligence, crowd wisdom, and decentralized decision making.
People in these herds are broken up into two groups, explains Friedrich Nietzsche, a philosopher who coined the phrase. One lended itself to the religious points of views- their beliefs and how those dictated their actions- while the other lended itself to influence by the media- based upon what others perceive as ‘right’ (following trends, social norms, etc.). Nietzsche perceived these two forms of subservience to be a weakness among the common man, and that the “Superman” as Nietzsche terms is the one who overcomes the values of the fallible herd.
I leave you with this. I want to circle back to my initial two quotes I posted:
“It is not worth an intelligent man’s time to be in the majority. By definition, there are already enough people to do that.” – G. H. Hardy
“It is impossible to defeat an ignorant man in argument.”
Take a minute to stop and listen. Listen to what is being said to you. Take a second to put down your iPhone or texting device. Take a minute to see if you are following or leading. Find out if you are reacting or making decisions. Find out if you are imploring change or just accepting status quo. If you really want to make a different and be an innovator of change. Step out of the majority, step out of the shadows of the “Norm”. No need to argue with an ignorant man, but there is a need to educate them to accomplish common goals. I am not saying we all have the answers, but we all have the ability to ask the questions that could lead to the answers which influence change and progress.





